Stress in the City
Melissa Mares cover how urban living affects mental health and how Illinoise stacks up in terms of resources
By MELISSA MARES
On
February 14, 2008, a gunman entered a lecture hall at Northern Illinois
University and opened fire, killing 5 people and wounding 16 more
before taking his own life. The shooter was later identified as Steven
Kazmierczak, a 27-year-old graduate student with a history of
psychiatric problems. By many accounts, Kazmierczak had seemed to have
his mental illness under control and was living a normal life leading
up to his death, and his actions came as a shock to his family,
teachers and friends.
It is easy to be
unaware of how widespread mental illness is until an event like the NIU
shootings receives extensive news coverage. But millions of Americans
suffer from mental illness every day, and millions more watch a loved
one suffer from a debilitating condition.
The
National Institute of Mental Health estimates that 26.2 percent of
Americans ages 18 and older (more than 57 million people) suffer from a
diagnosable mental disorder in a given year. Mental disorders are the
leading cause of disability in the United States and Canada for people
aged 15 to 44. According to data from the Global Burden of Disease
study completed by the World Health Organization, the World Bank and
Harvard University, mental illness accounts for more than 15 percent of
the burden of disease in the world’s market economies, which is more
than that caused by all cancers.
People living with mental illness can face very different realities depending on where they live. An individual’s environment does have an impact on the ways they may suffer with mental illness.
It
is easy for someone who is severely mentally ill to “hide out” in a
large city because of the volume of people and the anonymity that urban
living can provide, says Thomas Kinley, program director for the
Thresholds Dincin Center in the Lincoln Park neighborhood of Chicago.
Kinley started at Thresholds in 1981 and has been program director
since 1990. Thresholds is the oldest and largest mental health
non-profit orgnization in Illinois.
The
mentally ill in cities may have more ready access to services and care
for their disease. While more rural areas can often be more
community-oriented and people might band together to get help for
someone who is clearly suffering, the same resources might not be
available in a rural community. For these reasons, experts say it’s
hard to say whether the mentally ill or those with mental health issues
fare better in an urban or rural setting.
Whether
living a rural or urban lifestyle, experts seem to agree that the state
of Illinois is not a particularly good place for someone who suffers
from mental illness.
The
University of Illinois Institute of Government and Public Affairs
(IGPA) published a report in March 2007 to the Illinois General
Assembly entitled “State Funding of Community Agencies for Services
Provided to Illinois with Mental Illness and/or Developmental
Disabilities.”
In it the
researchers write, “Illinois’ funding of [mental health] and
[developmental disability] services is low compared to other states, as
indicated by the relatively few people who are served, and as measured
at the community agency level by the share of program costs reimbursed
with dedicated state funds.”
The report states that Illinois’ funding is inadequate for services for the mentally ill and developmentally disabled.
“In
fiscal year 2002, Illinois ranked 31st among the states in total per
capita spending on mental health services….A far lower proportion of
Illinois residents receive mental health services than nationally (1.2
percent in Illinois compared with 2 percent nationally).”
Even
more jarring is the National Alliance on Mental Illness’ (NAMI) most
recent nationwide “report card” on America’s health care system for
serious mental illness. The 2006 NAMI “report card” gave the state of
Illinois an “F” as an overall grade.
“Illinois’
grade of ‘F’ was well-deserved,” says Suzanne M. Andriukaitis,
executive director of NAMI of Greater Chicago, in an interview
conducted via email. “The problem with our mental health service
delivery system in Illinois is that it is not funded well enough. The
demand is greater than the supply in every area of treatment services.
As one of the richest states in terms of per-capita income, it is
disgraceful that Illinois ranks at the bottom when it comes to caring
for some of the most vulnerable of our citizens—the mentally ill.”
Thresholds
says it hopes it’s one place to which the mentally ill in Illinois can
turn. The organization serves 6,000 people per year, with 30 service
locations and 75 housing developments in the Chicagoland area. Mental
illnesses, such as schizophrenia, severe depression, bipolar disorder
among others, often render people unable to hold a job and secure
housing, which can start them down a path that leads to substance
abuse, prison or homelessness—and sometimes all three. Because they
often lack health coverage and a support system, many do not get care.
These are the challenges Thresholds’ members grapple with every day.
Thresholds
has several hundred beds for members who do not have housing or need
more extensive monitoring and treatment. But all of those beds are
full, and there can be a two-year waiting list for a bed, Kinley says.
While
severe mental illness is quite common, even more people suffer from an
array of less serious mental health issues, including more moderate
depressions, stress-related issues, anxiety and other ailments.
Depending on their severity, these conditions may not turn an
individual’s life upside down like a more severe illness would, but
these do cause problems for many Americans in both rural and urban
areas.
In his work as
founding director of the Roosevelt University Stress Institute, Dr.
Jonathan C. Smith begins with patients by evaluating the environmental
issues that cause stress in his patients. Noise, pollution, traffic—all
of these things can cause stress in urban dwellers.
“Urban living is complex,” says Smith.
He
emphasizes that the deciding factor for the amount of stress urban
living causes is how comfortable the individual is living in an urban
area.
“People who like urban
living…will hate living on a farm,” Smith says. “Stick a farmer in a
city, they will be stressed.” So it’s not the urban environment itself
as much as how comfortable the individual is in that environment, Smith
says.
Smith says that stress
is at least half-created by the individual, and his patients work to
make changes in their lives to reduce the stressors at the same time
that they learn relaxation techniques and coping skills. ..Smith says
most stress can be reduced or erased by doing one of three things:
“relax, change it, rethink it.” He teaches patients to “catch
themselves in the act” of having thoughts that contribute to feeling
highly stressed.
Stress-related
problems can seem minor compared to schizophrenia and other severe
disorders, but experts agree that stress can have very serious
consequences for both mental and physical well-being.
“Stress makes your body more vulnerable to and slower to recover from basically every illness,” Smith says.
Doctors
used to discuss certain ailments as especially “stress-related”, such
as ulcers, Smith says. “Now we know that stress wears your body down
and hurts recovery.”
Studies have found
that stress causes wounds to heal more slowly than they would under
less stressful conditions. One example of this is a study by
researchers at Ohio State University, published in Psychosomatic
Medicine in 1998. This study found that wounds healed an
average of three days slower in students stressed from taking
examinations than they did during summer vacation. There are many
examples of other studies that have had similar findings.
In
the same way, Dr. Smith says that people who practice relaxation
techniques can reverse some of the effects of stress. The Roosevelt
University Stress Institute teaches yoga, meditation, breathing,
visualization, progressive muscle relaxation and autogenic training, or
the thinking of repeated hypnotic thoughts.
Even
with these techniques, Smith says the first and most important part of
managing mental health and especially stress is to remain mindful of
stress levels and be aware of the times when things begin to feel
unmanageable so individuals can seek help.
“People
become numb to their own stress in the way we tune out subways, air
conditioners” and other white noise aspects of our environments, Smith
says.
On the Web:
Published: June 23, 2008
Issue: Summer 2008 Urban Living
Comments
DIncin Center
Kinely is nothing but a ponytail running a clubhouse for thugs, no mental health treatment takes place there. Shut it down!
Former member, Jul-18-2013